TAM Seminar on Quality of Educational Programmes Held in Almaty

On 11-12 November 2026, the National Erasmus+ Office in Kazakhstan and the Team of Higher Education Reform Experts (HERE) held a two-day Technical Assistance Mission (TAM) seminar entitled “Quality of Educational Programmes” at Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University in Almaty with the support of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (MSHE RK) and European Education and Culture Executive Agency (EACEA). The seminar opened with welcoming remarks by Banu Narbekova, Vice-Rector for Academic Activities at Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University and HERE member.

The seminar brought together more than 70 participants from 37 higher education institutions representing 12 cities across Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan, including university leaders, academic staff, quality assurance professionals, employers and other stakeholders in higher education.

Through expert presentations, group discussions and practical exercises, participants shared experiences, discussed current challenges and developed recommendations for strengthening quality assurance in higher education.

During the seminar, participants explored the following topics:

  • Internal quality assurance systems and institutional responsibility for building a culture of quality
  • Ways to align educational programmes and learning outcomes with labour market needs and professional standards
  • The role of employers in the development and review of educational programmes
  • Accreditation, international rankings and external quality assurance as tools for continuous improvement
  • The recognition and quality assurance of micro-credentials
  • The alignment of licensing and accreditation systems with the National Qualifications Framework.
  • The sessions were led by Fabrice Hénard, an expert in the European Higher Education Area (EHEA), Founder and Director of Learning Avenue Consultancy and former CEO, International Network for Quality Assurance Agencies in Higher Education (INQAAHE).

The programme also featured contributions from representatives of Kazakhstani universities, national accreditation agencies and other relevant organisations, who shared their professional experience and perspectives on quality assurance in higher education.

The speakers and contributors included:

  • Gulvira Akybayeva, Vice-Rector for Academic Affairs, Astana IT University
  • Yuliya Idiyatova, Director of the Department of Strategy and Corporate Governance, Qazaq AI Research University
  • Alibek Madibekov, Director of the National Center for Higher Education Development of the MSHE RK and member of the HERE team
  • Temirzhan Abdikhalyk, Head of the office for Higher Education Curriculum Management of the National Center for Higher Education Development of the MSHE RK
  • Elmira Auezova, Chair of the Sectoral Council of the Regional Chamber of Entrepreneurs «Atameken»
  • Alua Talgarkyzy, Deputy Director of the Department of Analysis and Development of Methodological Support of the JSC «Center for Labour Resources»
  • Olga Yanovskaya, Advisor to the Director General, Independent Agency for Accreditation and Rating
  • Zhandos Baizhuma, Director of the Center for Strategic Development, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University
  • Amantay Nurmagambetov, Advisor to the Director of the National Center for Higher Education Development of the MSHE RK

Major outcomes of the seminar:

  1. Strengthened understanding of institutional quality culture and internal quality assurance: The seminar enhanced participants’ understanding of the transition from a compliance-based approach to a culture of quality and continuous improvement in higher education institutions. Particular attention was given to institutional accountability, leadership responsibility, student involvement, evidence-based decision-making and the effective use of internal quality management systems.

  2. Improved understanding of the alignment of educational programmes with labour market needs: Participants explored European and Kazakhstani approaches to ensuring the relevance of educational programmes through the integration of professional standards, clearly defined learning outcomes, employer engagement and graduate employability evidence. The practical exercise provided an opportunity to consider how occupational standards can inform curriculum development and periodic programme review.

  3. Clarification of the complementary roles of accreditation, rankings and external quality assurance: The seminar highlighted the different purposes and limitations of accreditation, benchmarking and international rankings. Participants gained a better understanding of how external quality assurance mechanisms and international comparisons can contribute to institutional transparency, accountability and quality enhancement rather than being treated merely as compliance or reputational exercises.

  4. Identification of key issues concerning the recognition and quality assurance of micro-credentials: The discussions provided an overview of European developments and institutional practices in micro-credential provision and recognition. Key issues included common definitions, transparency, portability, stackability and quality assurance arrangements. The stakeholder discussion helped identify priority questions requiring coordinated attention from higher education institutions, government authorities and quality assurance bodies.

  5. Development of a shared vision for a more coherent quality assurance and qualifications framework in Kazakhstan: The seminar facilitated dialogue on the relationship between licensing, accreditation and qualifications frameworks, emphasising the need for clear institutional responsibilities, appropriate evidence requirements and coordinated review mechanisms. The final roadmap workshop enabled participants to identify potential overlaps and gaps, formulate priority actions and consider responsible actors and indicative implementation timelines.

The two-day seminar provided a valuable platform for exchanging experiences, strengthening cooperation and developing practical recommendations. The discussions and recommendations will contribute to ongoing efforts to enhance the quality and relevance of higher education in Kazakhstan and strengthen its international competitiveness.

Materials from the event are available here.

Image